Netflix’s Wednesday has become a worldwide sensation, racking up over 1 billion hours watched and turning its gothic world into a global pop culture moment. With its quirky charm, mysterious storytelling, and unforgettable characters, it’s no wonder the show has earned its place among Netflix’s elite.
But what if the cast looked a little different? Imagine a Hollywood reimagining with some of the biggest names in the industry stepping into the dark and twisted halls of Nevermore Academy. We’ve done just that—recasting the beloved series with A-list actors who could bring a fresh and fascinating twist to every role.
1. Wednesday Addams — Zendaya
Zendaya’s effortless cool, quick wit, and intense screen presence make her a dream fit for the role of Wednesday. Her past performances in Euphoria and Dune show she can balance vulnerability and edge, which is exactly what this character needs. She could easily deliver Wednesday’s dark humor with elegance and a quiet fire.
Video:
Wednesday Addams
2. Fester Addams — Jonah Hill
Uncle Fester is eccentric, unpredictable, and hilarious—qualities that Jonah Hill could embody perfectly. With his sharp comedic timing and ability to tap into emotional depth, Hill would give Fester that chaotic energy fans adore, while also making him surprisingly relatable.
3. Larissa Weems — Meryl Streep
There’s only one person who could bring the same level of poise, mystery, and control to Nevermore’s headmistress as Gwendoline Christie—Meryl Streep. She would command the screen with her every glance, making Weems feel both maternal and quietly threatening. The layers she could bring to the role? Unmatched.
4. Marilyn Thornhill — Zooey Deschanel
With her signature quirky charm, Zooey Deschanel would be an unexpected yet intriguing pick for Thornhill, the botany teacher hiding a dark side. Zooey could play sweet and disarming while slowly unraveling something more sinister, making her ideal for this deceptively complex character.
Video:
WEDNESDAY (1×1) Meeting Miss Thornhill
5. Valerie Kinbott — Blake Lively
As the well-meaning but nosy therapist, Blake Lively would add both beauty and charisma to the role. Her warm yet polished energy would make Kinbott likable—maybe a little too likable—until cracks in the surface start to show. She has the star power to make every scene pop.
6. Morticia Addams — Angelina Jolie
This is a match made in gothic heaven. Angelina Jolie’s mysterious beauty, magnetic aura, and commanding presence make her the ultimate Morticia. With her history of powerful roles and timeless glamour, she could deliver every line with silky elegance and lethal charm.
7. Gomez Addams — Antonio Banderas
As Morticia’s devoted and passionate husband, Antonio Banderas brings the perfect mix of suave confidence and theatrical flair. He’d light up every scene with charm, warmth, and just the right amount of madness. His chemistry with Jolie would be fiery and unforgettable.
8. Pugsley Addams — Gaten Matarazzo
Gaten Matarazzo, best known for Stranger Things, has that loveable oddball energy that makes him a perfect match for Pugsley. He could bring humor, heart, and a touch of mischief to the role, giving Pugsley more personality than ever.
9. Donovan Galpin — Jason Statham
Tough, no-nonsense, and intimidating—Jason Statham fits the role of Sheriff Galpin like a glove. His intense screen presence and action-star background would give Galpin the edge needed to balance his growing suspicions about Nevermore and his complicated relationship with his son.
10. Bianca Barclay — Zoë Kravitz
Bianca is confident, competitive, and layered—and Zoë Kravitz has the range to nail all of it. She brings a quiet strength and stylish presence to every role, and she’d add new dimensions to Bianca, making her more than just a rival to Wednesday.
Bonus: A Bit of Addams Family History
The world of Wednesday wouldn’t exist without the original creation of The Addams Family, which began as a cartoon strip by Charles Addams in The New Yorker back in 1938. It later inspired the iconic 1964 TV show, which introduced the world to a wealthy, delightfully macabre family who turned traditional American family values on their head. Over the decades, The Addams Family has lived on through films, books, games, and music, becoming a cornerstone of pop culture’s spooky side.
Bonus: Christina Ricci’s Surprising Return
Christina Ricci famously played Wednesday Addams in the 1990s films, defining the character for an entire generation. In a twist of fate, she returned in Netflix’s reboot—not as Wednesday, but as Marilyn Thornhill, the sly teacher with secrets. Interestingly, Jenna Ortega revealed that Ricci didn’t offer advice or direction, letting Ortega develop her own version of the character, keeping both portrayals distinct and original.
What About a European Cast?
Now that we’ve dreamed up a Hollywood version, imagine a European take. Picture Eva Green as Morticia, Daniel Brühl as Gomez, and Florence Pugh as Wednesday. The possibilities are endless—and exciting.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re obsessed with the current Wednesday series or just love a good fan-casting session, it’s fun to reimagine beloved stories with a new twist. This Hollywood fantasy cast could bring a different energy to the world of Nevermore—glamorous, gritty, and wildly entertaining.
Who would make your dream cast? Let your imagination run wild and keep the spooky creativity flowing.
